We love this pink Herve Ledger by Max Azria bandage dress! It's no wonder that it looks great on both girls.

But there can only be one winner in the who wore it best battle and it's up to you Sugarscapers to decide!

Hairspray's Amanda Bynes wore hers first, nearly nine months ago to the Critic's Choice Awards... Keeping it simple with black peep toes, a gold clutch, long luscious (we're jealous!) blonde locks and a dazzling Hollywood smile, Amanda looks every bit the glamourous goddess.

Melrose Place actress Katie Cassidy wore hers more recently to a Pre-Emmys bash... Katie gave the dress a more edgy feel with strappy sandals, black nail varnish, chunky earrings and a choppy hair style.

So which look wins for you? Is it the edgy take on the dress or Amanda's more simple approach?